Low Countries · Italy · France · 1420–1920

Across the Alps

For five hundred years, painters in the Low Countries, Italy and France kept taking from each other. Oil paint went south. Perspective and the antique went north. Caravaggio’s shadows went to Utrecht, Rubens’s colour went to Paris, and in the end nearly everyone went to Paris. This page follows the ideas, the pictures and the people who carried them.

How to use it. The timeline and the map play in steps: press Next or Play, or click a stage and use the arrow keys. Click any painting to see it larger.

Pairs. Most chapters set a source beside its echo, with a line on what crossed.

Low CountriesItalyFrance
Self-Portrait with the ColosseumMaarten van Heemskerck · 1553 · Fitzwilliam Museum, CambridgePainted in Haarlem, seventeen years after he came home. In the background a small figure sits sketching the ruin: Heemskerck as a young man in Rome.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

Overview

Five hundred years of crossings

Each arrow below is one crossing: an idea, a painting or a painter that carried something from one tradition into another. Arrows start in the colour of the tradition they came from and point to the one they reached. The three lanes run north to south, the way the journeys did. Step through the eras and watch the current change direction.

Arrows between three lanes, Low Countries at top, France in the middle, Italy at the bottom, placed by year from 1420 to 1920.
    All crossings as a list

      The routes

      Who went where

      The same story on a map. A grey line is a trip out to learn. A coloured line carried something, in the colour of where that something came from. Most northern painters went to Rome and came back changed, so their trips draw a lens: grey out, red home.

      A map of western Europe from the North Sea to Sicily with the arc of the Alps. Curved lines show journeys of painters, paintings and prints for the selected era.

          Prologue · 1420–1450

          Two ways of seeing

          In the 1420s and 1430s, two cities a thousand kilometres apart reinvented painting at the same time, in opposite ways.

          In Bruges and Ghent, Jan van Eyck and his circle perfected painting in oil: pigment ground in linseed oil and laid on in thin, transparent layers called glazes. Light passes through the layers and bounces back, so colours glow. Oil dries slowly, so a painter can blend and refine for weeks. The result was a new appetite for describing things: every hair, every reflection, every bead of a rosary. Space was built by eye, one convincing object at a time.

          In Florence, Brunelleschi had shown around 1415–20 how to construct space with geometry, and in 1435 Leon Battista Alberti wrote it down in On Painting: pick a vanishing point, draw a grid, and every line obeys. Masaccio painted bodies with weight and shadow. Florentines worked mostly in fresco and egg tempera, studied ancient statues, and aimed to measure the world rather than inventory it.

          Bruges: describeFlorence: measure
          The Arnolfini PortraitJan van Eyck · 1434 · National Gallery, LondonPainted in Bruges for a merchant family from Lucca. Brass, fur, oranges, a dog, and a convex mirror that shows the whole room again.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          same
          decade
          Holy TrinityMasaccio · about 1425–27 · Santa Maria Novella, FlorenceOne of the first paintings built with a single vanishing point. The painted chapel reads as a real hole in the church wall.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

          The point. Neither city had both. For the next century each half of Europe wanted what the other had: Italians wanted Flemish oil, light and faces; Northerners wanted Italian space, anatomy and antiquity.

          The trade routes were already open. Italian banks kept branches in Bruges, the great market of the north; the Medici opened theirs in 1439. The couple in the Arnolfini Portrait belonged to a merchant family from Lucca. The most famous early Netherlandish painting is a picture of Italians.

          France sat on the road between. Its most gifted painter of the period, Jean Fouquet of Tours, went to Rome in the 1440s and painted the pope. Back home he did something neither school did alone: a Netherlandish portrait in an Italian building.

          I · 1450–1500

          Low Countries → Italy

          Oil goes south

          For the second half of the fifteenth century the current ran mostly one way. Italian princes and bankers bought Netherlandish paintings, hired Netherlandish painters, and praised them in writing. Around 1456 the humanist Bartolomeo Facio, at the court of Naples, put Jan van Eyck and Rogier van der Weyden among the great painters of the age. King Alfonso of Naples owned their work; so did the Medici and the Este of Ferrara.

          Rogier himself came to Rome for the Jubilee of 1450. The Entombment he painted for the Medici shows the exchange in a single picture: a Florentine layout, borrowed from a panel by Fra Angelico, filled with northern faces and northern oil.

          Antonello brings oil to Venice

          Antonello da Messina, a Sicilian, trained in Naples, where Alfonso’s Netherlandish panels could be studied. Giorgio Vasari later claimed Antonello travelled to Bruges and prised the secret of oil from van Eyck himself; the dates make that impossible. But he mastered the technique, and when he spent 1475–76 in Venice he showed the city what oil could do. Giovanni Bellini, the leading Venetian painter, changed over. Through Bellini, oil passed to Giorgione and Titian, and Venetian colour was born.

          Saint Jerome in his StudyAntonello da Messina · about 1475 · National Gallery, LondonIn 1529 a Venetian connoisseur noted that some people took it for a van Eyck or a Memling. Antonello was Sicilian.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          1475 → 1501
          Doge Leonardo LoredanGiovanni Bellini · 1501–02 · National Gallery, LondonBellini moved to oil after Antonello’s stay in Venice. Look at the light on the damask and the buttons.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

          What crossed: oil glazing and its light: soft transitions, translucent shadows, surfaces that glint. Antonello’s Jerome sits in a northern interior; Bellini’s doge wears a northern glow.

          The altarpiece that changed Florence

          Tommaso Portinari ran the Medici bank in Bruges. Around 1475 he ordered an enormous altarpiece from Hugo van der Goes for his family’s church in Florence. It arrived in 1483. Florentine painters had seen nothing like it: life-size peasants with rough hands and stubble, flowers in a glass and a jar you could pick up, a winter landscape of bare trees.

          The Portinari Altarpiece, central panelHugo van der Goes · about 1475–76 · Uffizi, FlorenceOrdered in Bruges by Tommaso Portinari, who ran the Medici bank there. It reached Florence in 1483. The centre panel alone is three metres wide.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          Shepherds, from the Portinari AltarpieceHugo van der Goes · about 1475–76 · Uffizi, FlorenceRough hands, open mouths, particular faces. Florentine shepherds had been graceful extras; these are farm workers.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          1483 → 1485
          Adoration of the ShepherdsDomenico Ghirlandaio · 1485 · Sassetti Chapel, Santa Trinita, FlorenceTwo years after the Portinari Altarpiece went on show, Ghirlandaio’s shepherds arrive with the same weathered, adoring faces, in Florentine tempera.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

          What crossed: the shepherds. Ghirlandaio kept his Florentine composition, his Roman sarcophagus and his tempera, but his shepherds are Hugo’s: individual, weathered, astonished.

          A portrait format

          Florentines and Venetians in Bruges had their portraits painted by Hans Memling and took them home. Memling turned the sitter three-quarters toward us, let the hands rest at the bottom edge, and opened a landscape behind the head. Italian painters adopted the whole package. You can see it in Perugino, then in Raphael’s portraits and in the Mona Lisa.

          Man with a Roman Coin (Bernardo Bembo?)Hans Memling · about 1471–74 · Royal Museum of Fine Arts, AntwerpProbably a Venetian ambassador, painted in Bruges. Three-quarter view, a hand at the frame’s edge, an open landscape behind.KMSKA Antwerp · Wikimedia Commons · CC0
          1470s → 1494
          Francesco delle OperePietro Perugino · 1494 · Uffizi, FlorenceMemling’s format almost exactly: three-quarter view, hands resting on the lower edge, a soft landscape behind the head.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

          What crossed: a way of framing a person: three-quarter view, hands at the edge, landscape behind.

          II · 1500–1570

          Italy → Low Countries

          Rome goes north

          Then the current reversed. Rome under Julius II and Leo X held Michelangelo’s Sistine ceiling, Raphael’s rooms and the newly dug-up statues of antiquity, and northern painters began to treat a trip there as part of their training. Art historians call them the Romanists.

          Jan Gossaert went in 1508–09 in the train of Philip of Burgundy and drew the ancient statues. Back home he painted mythological nudes on a scale no Netherlandish painter had tried. Jan van Scorel ran the papal collection of antiquities for Adrian VI, the only Dutch pope, before returning to Utrecht. Maarten van Heemskerck filled sketchbooks with ruins in 1532–36, and twenty years later painted himself in front of the Colosseum, the picture at the top of this page.

          Works came north too. A family of Bruges merchants bought a marble Madonna from Michelangelo and shipped it home in 1506. When Leo X wanted tapestries for the Sistine Chapel, he turned to the best weavers in Europe, in Brussels, so Raphael’s full-size designs went there in 1516. They stayed there for years, studied by every painter who could get in to see them, while the woven tapestries went back south to hang in the chapel from 1519.

          Faster than painters: prints

          The cheapest carrier of all was paper. Marcantonio Raimondi made engravings of Raphael’s designs, and they sold across Europe. Marcantonio also copied Dürer’s woodcuts, and according to Vasari, Dürer went to the Venetian authorities to complain: one of the earliest copyright disputes on record. From 1548 the Antwerp publisher Hieronymus Cock printed Italian compositions by the thousand. A painter in Haarlem who never left home could own Raphael on a sheet of paper.

          The Judgment of ParisMarcantonio Raimondi after Raphael · engraving, about 1510–20 · National Gallery of Art, WashingtonRaphael drew it, Marcantonio engraved it, and printers sold copies across Europe. Keep an eye on the three figures at the bottom right.National Gallery of Art · Wikimedia Commons · CC0

          Remember this print. The three figures at the bottom right turn up again in Paris, 350 years later, in chapter IX.

          The one who brought back mountains

          Pieter Bruegel the Elder crossed the Alps around 1552 and reached Rome and the south. He came home with drawings of mountains, not statues, and spent his career painting Flemish peasants and seasons. Italy shows up in him sideways: his Tower of Babel is the Colosseum, swollen to biblical size and dropped beside a Flemish port.

          III · 1516–1600

          Italy → France ← Low Countries

          France buys Italy

          French kings had marched into Italy repeatedly since 1494 and came back wanting what they had seen. Francis I bought it wholesale. In 1516 he invited Leonardo da Vinci to live at Amboise; Leonardo brought the Mona Lisa and died there in 1519. Andrea del Sarto came from Florence in 1518. Rosso Fiorentino arrived in 1530 and Francesco Primaticcio in 1532 to decorate the king’s palace at Fontainebleau, and the goldsmith Benvenuto Cellini followed in 1540.

          Rosso and Primaticcio invented something that existed in neither country before: painted panels framed by high stucco figures, all elongated limbs and garlands. French artists copied it, prints spread it, and it became the School of Fontainebleau, a style that spread through France and beyond.

          But look at who painted the king’s face. Portraits at the French court were a Netherlandish speciality. Jean Clouet, Francis I’s court portraitist, probably came from the southern Netherlands; Corneille de Lyon came from The Hague. So French court art in the sixteenth century was Italian on the walls and ceilings and Netherlandish in the portraits.

          IV · 1600–1630

          Italy → Utrecht, France

          Caravaggio’s shadow

          In 1600 Caravaggio unveiled two paintings of Saint Matthew in San Luigi dei Francesi, the French national church in Rome. Ordinary people in street clothes, lit by a single hard beam out of darkness: it was the most talked-about painting in the city, and foreign painters in Rome went to see it.

          Three of them came from Utrecht, a city with a large Catholic community inside the Protestant Dutch Republic. Hendrick ter Brugghen was in Italy from about 1604 to 1614, Gerard van Honthorst from about 1610 to 1620, Dirck van Baburen from about 1612 to 1620. They came home with half-length figures pushed up against the picture surface, candlelight, dirty feet, and drinkers and musicians painted life-size. They are known as the Utrecht Caravaggisti.

          The Calling of Saint MatthewCaravaggio · 1599–1600 · San Luigi dei Francesi, RomeA beam of light, a counting table, men in street clothes. It hangs in the French national church in Rome, where painters from the north came to look.Photo Gleb Simonov · Wikimedia Commons · CC0
          1600 → 1621
          The Calling of Saint MatthewHendrick ter Brugghen · 1621 · Centraal Museum, UtrechtThe same story, painted in Utrecht seven years after ter Brugghen came home: half-length figures, raking light, coins on the table.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

          What crossed: the subject, the shaft of light and the tavern-table staging. Ter Brugghen crops in tighter and lightens the palette: a Dutch accent on a Roman sentence.

          Caravaggio reached France through the same door. Valentin de Boulogne settled in Rome and painted like a Caravaggio follower for the rest of his short life. Simon Vouet spent fourteen years in Italy, and Louis XIII called him back in 1627 to be First Painter to the King. In Lorraine, Georges de La Tour painted candlelit saints of eerie stillness. Nobody knows whether he ever went to Rome; the Utrecht painters are one likely route.

          And the Utrecht pictures kept travelling inside the Dutch Republic. Baburen’s Procuress belonged, as an original or a copy, to Vermeer’s mother-in-law. Vermeer painted it into the background of two of his own interiors.

          The ProcuressDirck van Baburen · 1622 · Museum of Fine Arts, BostonPainted in Utrecht two years after Baburen came back from Rome: big figures, close up, under hard light.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          1622 → 1664
          The ConcertJohannes Vermeer · about 1664 · stolen from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in 1990On the wall at right: Baburen’s Procuress. Vermeer’s mother-in-law owned the picture, or a copy of it.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

          What crossed: a whole painting, hung on Vermeer’s painted wall. Caravaggio’s idea had become Dutch furniture.

          V · 1600–1640

          Italy → Antwerp and Amsterdam

          The one who went, and the one who didn’t

          The two greatest painters of the Low Countries in the seventeenth century show the two ways Italy could get into a northern painter.

          Rubens went. He spent 1600 to 1608 in Italy, mostly as court painter to the Gonzaga in Mantua, with long stays in Rome and Genoa and a mission to Spain. He copied everything: Titian, Michelangelo, ancient sculpture, even Leonardo’s lost Battle of Anghiari, known only from earlier copies. Back in Antwerp he painted The Elevation of the Cross for the cathedral and announced a new Flemish art built from Italian parts. His pupil Anthony van Dyck went south too, and in Genoa in the 1620s invented the cool, tall aristocratic portrait.

          Rembrandt didn’t. Around 1630 the statesman Constantijn Huygens urged him and his friend Jan Lievens to make the trip. They told him they were too busy, and that the best Italian paintings could be seen in Holland anyway. They were nearly right. Rembrandt’s teacher, Pieter Lastman, had been to Rome. And Amsterdam had become the richest art market in Europe, where Italian masterpieces came up for sale.

          On 9 April 1639 Raphael’s portrait of Baldassare Castiglione was auctioned in Amsterdam from the collection of Lucas van Uffelen, a merchant who had lived in Venice. Rembrandt was there and sketched it. The buyer, Alfonso Lopez, also owned a Titian portrait of a man leaning on a ledge. Within a year Rembrandt had etched and then painted himself in their pose.

          Source
          Baldassare CastiglioneRaphael · about 1514–15 · Louvre, ParisAuctioned in Amsterdam in April 1639. Rembrandt was in the room.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          Source
          Portrait of a ManTitian · about 1510 · National Gallery, LondonOnce thought to be the poet Ariosto. In 1639 it hung in the Amsterdam house of the collector Alfonso Lopez.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          At the sale, 1639
          Sketch after Raphael’s CastiglioneRembrandt · 1639 · Albertina, ViennaDrawn at the sale. Rembrandt noted the price, 3,500 guilders, and already tipped the hat at a jauntier angle.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          Result, 1640
          Self-Portrait at the Age of 34Rembrandt · 1640 · National Gallery, LondonA year later: Raphael’s pose and Titian’s sleeve on the ledge, worn by a Dutch painter who never went to Italy.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

          What crossed: two Italian poses, merged. Raphael’s turned body and steady gaze, Titian’s arm and sleeve on the stone ledge, all without leaving Amsterdam.

          VI · 1620–1720

          France and Low Countries ⇄ Rome

          Rome, the finishing school

          In the seventeenth century Rome was full of foreigners, and some of the most “Italian” painting there was made by them. Two Frenchmen, Nicolas Poussin (in Rome from 1624) and Claude Lorrain (from about 1617), spent their working lives in the city. Poussin built severe, reasoned compositions out of Raphael and antique reliefs and sent them to collectors in Paris. Claude invented the ideal landscape: golden light, classical ruins, a calm sea. He learned part of it from northern landscape painters working in Rome, such as the Fleming Paul Bril.

          The Dutch and Flemish painters in Rome formed a club, the Bentvueghels (“birds of a flock”), from about 1620 until the pope banned it in 1720. New members got a nickname at an all-night, wine-soaked initiation that ended at the church of Santa Costanza, where some of their scratched names survive. One member, Pieter van Laer of Haarlem, nicknamed il Bamboccio, “the big baby”, sent influence the other way: his scenes of Roman street life, beggars and card players started a fashion in Rome for bambocciate that Italian critics hated.

          Others brought the south home. Jan Both spent about four years in Rome around 1638–41 and returned to Utrecht painting warm Italian light. Aelbert Cuyp of Dordrecht never went at all, but after seeing Both’s pictures he poured the same golden light over Dutch rivers and cows.

          Italian Landscape with a DraughtsmanJan Both · about 1650–52 · Rijksmuseum, AmsterdamBoth spent about four years in Rome. Back in Utrecht he kept painting warm Campagna light from memory.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          1640s → 1650
          The Maas at DordrechtAelbert Cuyp · about 1650 · National Gallery of Art, WashingtonCuyp never went to Italy. Through Both’s pictures, Roman light arrived on a Dutch river.National Gallery of Art · Wikimedia Commons · CC0

          What crossed: a light. Low sun, warm haze, long shadows: the Roman Campagna’s afternoon, moved to the Maas.

          Making it official. In 1666 France founded the French Academy in Rome. Winners of the Prix de Rome lived there for years at royal expense, copying antiquities and Raphael. The prize ran until 1968.

          VII · 1622–1720

          Flanders → Paris

          Colour against line

          In 1622 Marie de’ Medici, the Florentine widow of Henry IV of France, hired Rubens to paint her life for the Luxembourg Palace in Paris. He delivered 24 enormous canvases in 1625, painted in Antwerp: the queen’s birth, marriage and regency, crowded with gods, nymphs and allegories. A Flemish painter, an Italian queen, a French palace.

          The cycle hung in Paris as a permanent argument. In the 1670s the French Royal Academy split over it. The Poussinistes said drawing was the soul of painting, because it appeals to reason; Poussin was their model. The Rubénistes, led by the critic Roger de Piles, said colour was what made painting painting, and Rubens proved it. By 1699 de Piles was a member of the Academy, and colour had effectively won.

          The victory had a face. Antoine Watteau came from Valenciennes, a Flemish town that had become French only in 1678. In Paris he got access to the Luxembourg and studied the Medici cycle closely. His Pilgrimage to Cythera of 1717, which the Academy accepted under a new category invented for him, the fête galante, is Rubens made small, silky and melancholy. It opens the Rococo.

          The Disembarkation of Marie de’ Medici at MarseillesPeter Paul Rubens · 1622–25 · Louvre, ParisOne of 24 canvases for the Florentine-born queen of France: painted in Antwerp, for a palace in Paris.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          1625 → 1717
          Pilgrimage to CytheraAntoine Watteau · 1717 · Louvre, ParisWatteau studied the Medici cycle in the Luxembourg Palace. His feathery colour is Rubens made small and wistful.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

          What crossed: Rubens’s colour and movement: shimmering silk, feathery brushwork, figures that flow in a long chain across the canvas.

          VIII · 1700–1873

          Dutch Republic → Paris

          Paris collects the Dutch

          In the eighteenth century, Paris collectors fell for small Dutch pictures: kitchens, taverns, still lifes, quiet interiors. They hung beside French work in private cabinets, and French painters studied them. Jean Siméon Chardin built a career on the same subjects, painted in his own grainy, patient way.

          The MilkmaidJohannes Vermeer · about 1658 · Rijksmuseum, AmsterdamQuiet work in a plain room, lit from a window: the Dutch kind of picture that eighteenth-century Paris collected.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          Dutch genre → 1738
          The Kitchen MaidJean Siméon Chardin · 1738 · National Gallery of Art, WashingtonChardin probably never saw that Vermeer, but Paris was full of Dutch kitchen scenes. He took up the subject in his own grainy, still paint.National Gallery of Art · Wikimedia Commons · CC0

          What crossed: a subject and a mood: domestic work, a single figure, plain things in window light. Chardin is unlikely to have seen this particular Vermeer; it stands for a kind of picture Paris was buying.

          The museum of everything

          Then came the most violent crossing of all. The Louvre opened as a public museum in 1793. French revolutionary and Napoleonic armies sent it the Ghent Altarpiece’s central panels and Rubens’s Antwerp altarpieces in 1794, and Raphael’s Transfiguration and hundreds of Italian works after 1797. For about twenty years the Louvre was the one place on earth where you could walk from van Eyck to Raphael to Rubens in an afternoon. After Waterloo most of it went home, but a generation of French artists had trained in front of it.

          Vermeer, found in Paris

          Vermeer died in 1675 and was nearly forgotten. His pictures were sold under other names. In 1866 the French critic Théophile Thoré, writing as William Bürger, published a series of articles in the Gazette des Beaux-Arts that rebuilt his career and called him “the sphinx of Delft”. The rediscovery of the most Dutch of painters was a French achievement.

          Manet goes to Haarlem

          French realists and Impressionists found in Frans Hals exactly what the Academy disapproved of: brushstrokes left visible, laid on fast, wet into wet. In 1872 Édouard Manet made the trip to Haarlem to see the Hals paintings there. The next year he showed Le Bon Bock, a fat, happy drinker with a pipe, and had his first success at the Salon.

          The Merry DrinkerFrans Hals · about 1628–30 · Rijksmuseum, AmsterdamFast, visible strokes laid wet into wet. Nineteenth-century French painters treated Hals as a prophet.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          1628 → 1873
          Le Bon BockÉdouard Manet · 1873 · Philadelphia Museum of ArtPainted months after Manet’s trip to Haarlem to see Hals. The painter Alfred Stevens joked that the sitter was drinking Haarlem beer.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

          What crossed: the open, quick brushwork and the cheerful drinker. Two and a half centuries apart, nearly the same picture.

          IX · 1846–1920

          Low Countries → Paris ← Italy

          Paris, the crossroads

          By the nineteenth century the map had a single centre. Paris had the Salon, the dealers, the critics and the Louvre, and painters came from everywhere. Influence still crossed in both directions, but now it crossed in Paris.

          Remember Marcantonio’s engraving? In 1863 Manet built the scandal of the year, Le Déjeuner sur l’herbe, on its three seated river gods: same poses, same glance out at the viewer, now in modern clothes and a Paris wood.

          The Judgment of ParisMarcantonio Raimondi after Raphael · engraving, about 1510–20 · National Gallery of Art, WashingtonRaphael drew it, Marcantonio engraved it, and printers sold copies across Europe. Keep an eye on the three figures at the bottom right.National Gallery of Art · Wikimedia Commons · CC0
          1510s → 1863
          Le Déjeuner sur l’herbeÉdouard Manet · 1863 · Musée d’Orsay, ParisThe scandal of 1863. Its seated trio, poses and all, comes from Marcantonio’s engraving after Raphael, then 350 years old.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

          What crossed: a composition, by paper, across three and a half centuries. The quotation was the point: Manet set a Renaissance pose against modern life.

          A Dutchman teaches Monet to see

          Johan Barthold Jongkind moved from the Netherlands to Paris in 1846. In 1862 on the Normandy coast he met a young Claude Monet, and for several years they painted side by side, out of doors, chasing changing light and weather in quick strokes. Monet said he owed the final education of his eye to Jongkind.

          HonfleurJohan Barthold Jongkind · 1865 · Metropolitan Museum of Art, New YorkA Dutch painter on the Normandy coast, catching wet light and weather quickly, in the open air.Metropolitan Museum of Art · Wikimedia Commons · CC0
          1865 → 1872
          Impression, SunriseClaude Monet · 1872 · Musée Marmottan Monet, ParisThe picture that gave Impressionism its name. Monet said he owed the final education of his eye to Jongkind.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

          What crossed: the habit of painting fast in front of the motif, and of making weather, not buildings, the subject.

          Van Gogh in Paris

          The traffic ran back north as well. The Hague School of the 1870s took its grey, misty landscapes partly from French Barbizon painting, which Dutch collectors like H.W. Mesdag bought. Vincent van Gogh learned to paint in that tradition from his cousin-in-law Anton Mauve. In 1886 he went to Paris, met the Impressionists and the circle of Seurat and Signac, and his palette exploded.

          The Potato EatersVincent van Gogh · 1885 · Van Gogh Museum, AmsterdamPainted in Nuenen in the dark earth tones of the Hague School.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          1885 → 1887
          Self-Portrait with Grey Felt HatVincent van Gogh · 1887 · Van Gogh Museum, AmsterdamTwo years in Paris later: short strokes of pure, complementary colour, learned from the Impressionists and Seurat’s circle.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

          What crossed: pure colour, set in short complementary strokes. Two years in Paris turned Nuenen brown into Paris blue and orange.

          Italians in Paris

          Italian painters came too. Some Florentine painters saw French landscape painting at the Paris World’s Fair of 1855, and the Macchiaioli in Florence soon painted in bold patches of light and shade. Giuseppe De Nittis moved to Paris in 1867 and showed at the first Impressionist exhibition in 1874; Federico Zandomeneghi arrived the same year and joined the Impressionists. Later Amedeo Modigliani (1906) and the Futurists, who exhibited in Paris in 1912, helped make the city international.

          Coda: a tree becomes a grid

          In 1911 Piet Mondrian saw Cubist paintings by Picasso and Braque at an exhibition in Amsterdam. Within months he was in Paris. Stuck in the Netherlands during the First World War, he and his friends founded De Stijl in 1917, and back in Paris after the war he reduced painting to black lines and primary colours. The last great Dutch export to Paris was a grid.

          Gray TreePiet Mondrian · 1911 · Kunstmuseum Den HaagPainted in 1911, the year Mondrian first saw Cubist paintings by Picasso and Braque in Amsterdam. Within months he moved to Paris.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain
          1911 → 1921
          Composition with Large Red Plane, Yellow, Black, Grey and BluePiet Mondrian · 1921 · Kunstmuseum Den HaagTen years and a Paris studio later, the tree has become a grid.Wikimedia Commons · Public domain

          What crossed: Cubism, from Paris to Amsterdam and back, turned by a Dutch painter into something neither city had made.

          Patterns

          How a picture crosses the Alps

          Five carriers turn up again and again.

          • Painters travelled

            For three centuries Rome was a finishing school for northern painters: Gossaert, Heemskerck, Bruegel, Rubens, ter Brugghen, Both, and the French from Poussin to the Prix de Rome. Most came home, and their return trips carried the ideas.

          • Paintings travelled

            Bankers shipped altarpieces home, kings bought masterpieces, merchants auctioned them, armies looted them. One altarpiece, the Portinari, retrained a city’s painters; one auction gave Rembrandt his self-image.

          • Prints travelled fastest

            Engravings were cheap, light and endless. Marcantonio’s Raphael reached Antwerp workshops within years and Manet’s Paris 350 years later. Criticism worked the same way: Thoré-Bürger’s articles brought back Vermeer.

          • Money set the direction

            Influence followed the richest market: Bruges, where Italian banks bought northern paintings; Antwerp, the print and picture trade; Amsterdam, the great auction house; then Paris, with its collectors and dealers.

          • Every borrowing was a translation

            Nobody copied straight. Ghirlandaio put Flemish shepherds into Florentine tempera, Bruegel brought back mountains, Cuyp moved Roman light to Dordrecht, Watteau made Rubens small, Mondrian turned Cubism into a grid.

          Which way the current ran

          1. 1400s
            Low Countries → Italy

            Oil, light, faces and portrait formats go south.

          2. 1500s
            Italy → Low CountriesItaly → France

            Antiquity, anatomy and the nude go north; Italian artists build French court style.

          3. 1600s
            Rome → Utrecht, AntwerpFlanders → Paris

            Caravaggio’s light and the Baroque go north; Rubens settles the French argument about colour.

          4. 1700s
            Dutch Republic → Paris

            Dutch genre and still life shape French taste.

          5. 1800s
            / → Paris → /

            Everyone goes to Paris, and Paris sends it back: Hals to Manet, Jongkind to Monet, Paris to van Gogh and the Macchiaioli.

          Check yourself

          Where did it come from?

          Images and sources

          Paintings are public domain; photographs and scans come from Wikimedia Commons under the licences listed. Dates are approximate where the record is. Coastlines are from Natural Earth (public domain).

          1. Maarten van Heemskerck, Self-Portrait with the Colosseum, 1553. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          2. Jan van Eyck, The Arnolfini Portrait, 1434. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          3. Masaccio, Holy Trinity, about 1425–27. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          4. Hubert and Jan van Eyck, The Ghent Altarpiece, open, finished 1432. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          5. Jean Fouquet, Étienne Chevalier with Saint Stephen, about 1452–55. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          6. Rogier van der Weyden, The Entombment, about 1450. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          7. Hans Memling, The Last Judgment, 1467–71. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          8. Antonello da Messina, Saint Jerome in his Study, about 1475. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          9. Giovanni Bellini, Doge Leonardo Loredan, 1501–02. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          10. Hugo van der Goes, The Portinari Altarpiece, central panel, about 1475–76. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          11. Hugo van der Goes, Shepherds, from the Portinari Altarpiece, about 1475–76. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          12. Domenico Ghirlandaio, Adoration of the Shepherds, 1485. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          13. Hans Memling, Man with a Roman Coin (Bernardo Bembo?), about 1471–74. KMSKA Antwerp · Wikimedia Commons · CC0.
          14. Pietro Perugino, Francesco delle Opere, 1494. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          15. Jan Gossaert, Neptune and Amphitrite, 1516. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          16. Michelangelo, Madonna and Child, about 1501–04. Photo Jean-Pol Grandmont · Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 3.0.
          17. Raphael, The Miraculous Draught of Fishes, 1515–16. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          18. Marcantonio Raimondi after Raphael, The Judgment of Paris, engraving, about 1510–20. National Gallery of Art · Wikimedia Commons · CC0.
          19. Pieter Bruegel the Elder, The Tower of Babel, 1563. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          20. Leonardo da Vinci, Mona Lisa, about 1503–19. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          21. Rosso Fiorentino and workshop, Gallery of Francis I, 1533–39. Photo Frédéric Neupont · Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0.
          22. School of Fontainebleau, Gabrielle d’Estrées and One of Her Sisters, about 1594. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          23. attributed to Jean Clouet, Francis I, about 1530. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          24. Caravaggio, The Calling of Saint Matthew, 1599–1600. Photo Gleb Simonov · Wikimedia Commons · CC0.
          25. Hendrick ter Brugghen, The Calling of Saint Matthew, 1621. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          26. Gerard van Honthorst, Christ before the High Priest, about 1617. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          27. Georges de La Tour, Saint Joseph the Carpenter, about 1642. Photo Philippel · Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0.
          28. Dirck van Baburen, The Procuress, 1622. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          29. Johannes Vermeer, The Concert, about 1664. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          30. Peter Paul Rubens, Copy of Leonardo’s Battle of Anghiari, about 1603. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          31. Peter Paul Rubens, The Elevation of the Cross, 1610–11. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          32. Anthony van Dyck, Marchesa Elena Grimaldi Cattaneo, 1623. National Gallery of Art · Wikimedia Commons · CC0.
          33. Raphael, Baldassare Castiglione, about 1514–15. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          34. Titian, Portrait of a Man, about 1510. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          35. Rembrandt, Sketch after Raphael’s Castiglione, 1639. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          36. Rembrandt, Self-Portrait at the Age of 34, 1640. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          37. Nicolas Poussin, Et in Arcadia ego, about 1637–38. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          38. Claude Lorrain, Seaport with the Embarkation of the Queen of Sheba, 1648. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          39. Jan Both, Italian Landscape with a Draughtsman, about 1650–52. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          40. Aelbert Cuyp, The Maas at Dordrecht, about 1650. National Gallery of Art · Wikimedia Commons · CC0.
          41. Peter Paul Rubens, The Disembarkation of Marie de’ Medici at Marseilles, 1622–25. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          42. Antoine Watteau, Pilgrimage to Cythera, 1717. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          43. Johannes Vermeer, The Milkmaid, about 1658. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          44. Jean Siméon Chardin, The Kitchen Maid, 1738. National Gallery of Art · Wikimedia Commons · CC0.
          45. Hubert Robert, The Grande Galerie of the Louvre, about 1795. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          46. Johannes Vermeer, View of Delft, about 1660–61. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          47. Frans Hals, The Merry Drinker, about 1628–30. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          48. Édouard Manet, Le Bon Bock, 1873. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          49. Édouard Manet, Le Déjeuner sur l’herbe, 1863. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          50. Johan Barthold Jongkind, Honfleur, 1865. Metropolitan Museum of Art · Wikimedia Commons · CC0.
          51. Claude Monet, Impression, Sunrise, 1872. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          52. Vincent van Gogh, The Potato Eaters, 1885. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          53. Vincent van Gogh, Self-Portrait with Grey Felt Hat, 1887. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          54. Giuseppe De Nittis, Place des Pyramides, 1875. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          55. Piet Mondrian, Gray Tree, 1911. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.
          56. Piet Mondrian, Composition with Large Red Plane, Yellow, Black, Grey and Blue, 1921. Wikimedia Commons · Public domain.

          Further reading